Note

If posts do not appear immediately, please wait for a few seconds. For some reason, the blog sometimes takes a while to load. Thanks!

On Other Blogs: From Beirut to the Beltway

On Other Blogs: Jeha"s Nail - مسمار جحا

On Other Blogs: Blacksmiths of Lebanon

On Other Blogs:The Beirut Spring

Wednesday, March 04, 2009

Arrest Warrent Issued for Sudan's Bashir: Debunking the Arabist Line

Well the precedent has been set and an arrest warrant has been issued for President Bashir of Sudan. The warrant accuses him of war crimes and crimes against humanity, and needless to say the immediate Sudanese reaction has been one of condemnation of neocolonial white interference and bla bla bla. You know the drill. I also imagine the reaction on the nationalist quasi-leftist arab street to be of a similar nature. Naturally, the interference of the international community is to be condemned, while the killing of black africans is ok. The white man cannot interfere but it is fine for the arab to rampage... Lets take a look at the following sample from the angry arab.

This arrest warrant is a joke, of course and will not be taken seriously outside of the offices of the New York Times. I mean, let us say that Bashir (a lousy dictator with very low intelligence level and a skill in turning into a buffoon before a crowd, with a history of cooperation with Western governments--overt and covert) is responsible for much of the bloodshed in Darfur, his record pales by that (if you count the numbers of victims) of George W. Bush. I mean, will that body issue an arrest warrant for Bush or any American president if he/she were to drop a nuclear bomb on an entire country or continent? Of course, not. But then again: how can the White Man resist the temptation to preach and sermonize? The White Man can't resist that opportunity.


Alright, clearly there is anger there. But let us dissect the argument a little bit more carefully.

"The arrest warrant is a joke".
Maybe, but maybe not. It is certainly useless in the short term but in the long term it is not inconceivable that we see Bashir is shackles before a court of law. It happened in the former Yugoslavia, why not Sudan.

"Bashir's record pales in comparison to Bush's ...".
That is an irrelevant argument, since justice in one case does not preclude justice in another. Moreover, it is a subjective argument and relies on where one places value. If equal value is placed on all human life regardless of its ethnic composition, and if human suffering is condemned regardless of the color of its skin, then no, Bashir's record does not pale in comparison to Bush's. On the other hand, if one values Iraqi life more than Darfurian life, then perhaps it does pale... Also, I am not quite sure how that macabre calculation worked. Do we tally up all the dead in Iraq and Afghanistan regardless of who killed them (e.g., Iraqi Shias, Iraqi Sunnis, the Taliban...) , then add all the murders and rapes, regardless of who perpetrated them and assign the blame on all of them to Bush? I haven't done that ugly math, but I am sure that even then, Bashir's record does not pale in comparison to Bush's...

"How can the White Man resist the temptation to preach and sermonize?"
I don't know. But how does that differ from the Angry Arab man blaming the white man for everything? Was the self righteous white man on horseback in south Darfur killing and raping? Was the self righteous white man providing tank cover and air support agains the Darfurians? Or was it Bashir's rule that enabled those acts? When will the angry arab stop and unequivocally condemn atrocities committed by (seemingly) equally angry arab dictators. Preaching and sermonizing is one thing. Enabling atrocities is a different thing. It is Bashir who is on trial for war crimes here, not those who preached for his arrest.

Final Points
My main point in writing this post has been to deliver the following message. We need to resist the temptation to enable atrocities by using "yes, but..." arguments. Atrocities are bad. period. Those who commit them must be brought to justice. period. If there are other places in the world where atrocities are being committed, then the perpetrators should also be brought to justice. You wouldn't release one murderer because you can't catch another one, would you?

12 comments:

Unknown said...

International Criminal Court has demonstrated its moral authority by holding Omar al-Bashir president of Sudan responsible for his crimes, I believe the US is not rushing into arrest in order to avoid another situation like the Iraq. Does this mean we should turn a blind eye on crimes on humanity? Make your stance on the situation of arrest warrant for Omar al-Bashir at
www.allvoices.com/journalism
.

A Purple Monkey said...

Beautifully written RAT.

Lirun said...

interesting perspective

Cory said...

This was well said.

Angry Arab also ignores context in his criticism of Bush.

Not that I'm much of a fan of Mr. Bush, but the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan are not about genocide, or ethnic cleansing. Their purpose is not to kill.

On the other hand, atrocities in the Sudan are a routine part of the civil war in Darfur even though the UN and Amnesty International avoid the use of the term genocide.

As for his conjectures about the use of the bomb, well...there is no precedent for such an action (I would not consider the Second World War as a precedent given the unique circumstances of that time.) Maybe in the event of the use of the bomb the world would demand the enforcement of the IJC decision on the illegality of the use of nuclear weapons.

sewa mobil said...

Nice article, thanks.

marl said...

thanks alot for this amazing article.

Sappa Tamang said...

Annapurna Base Camp Trek start pokhara to ghorepani poon hill and continue to ABC Trekking, this trip can complete Annapurna Base Camp Trek 7 days as well and Also if have enough time can make Annapurna Base Camp Trek 10 days. Annapurna Base Camp Trek route is very beautiful and Perfect Himalayan scenery. the only make Annapurna Base Camp trek difficulty. June to August and JanuaryFebruary.Annapurna Base Camp Trek distance is around 200 miles. there are many Travel has been read Annapurna Base Camp Trek blog. September to

November is one of the Best Season makes the trek to Annapurna Base Camp.

Karma Eco Adventure Nepal said...

We, the team Karma Eco Adventure is a leading travel and trekking company based in Kathmandu Nepal dedicated to help travelers in the country with personally crafted tours and treks. Our featured packages as: Annapurna base camp trek, Annapurna circuit trek , Ghorepani poonhill trek, Annapurna sanctuary trek, Everest base camp heli trek , Everest base camp trek

Himalayan Adventure Treks and Tours said...

Awesome Article! very interesting and informative. Thanks for sharing.

www.himalayanadventuretreks.com

Himalayan Adventure Treks & Tours said...

The trek to the base camp of the world’s tallest mountain- the Mt. Everest (8848m) is filled with numerous natural attractions. Everest Base Camp Trek is one of the most popular trekking routes in the World. Likewise, the alluring nature with the majestic mountains in the background guarantees that you enjoy each moment on the trek. Moreover, you also visit many Sherpa villages, cultures, and monasteries on the trek.

Himalayan Local Guide Pvt. Ltd. said...

Annapurna Base Camp Trek is 10th highest mountain of the world, Mt Annapurna (8091m), during this 10 -day guided trip. Enjoy travelling through a diversified landscape consisting of both temperate and alpine forests, streams, highland pastures and rocky terrain punctuated by isolated mountain hamlets, temples and monasteries.

Mission Himalaya Treks said...

Best trekking packages offered by Mission Himalaya Treks:
Kanchenjunga South Base Camp Trek
Tilicho Lake Trek
Ruby Valley Trek
Manaslu Circuit Trek
Langtang Valley Trek
Everest Base Camp Trek
Annapurna Base Camp Trek